Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Insurance companies caught red-handed
Phillida Bunkle MP Tue Sep 14 1999
A complaint to the Commerce Commission by Alliance health spokesperson Phillida Bunkle has helped patients get reimbursements totalling $145,223 from medical insurance companies.
The insurance companies were telling patients that their policies would cover 80% of the real cost of an operation when in fact they would cover only 20%.
In December last year Phillida Bunkle wrote to the Commerce Commission about Aetna Insurance's 'Essential cover' policy which stated it would provide '80% reimbursement of expenses for medically necessary procedures based on reasonable charges, up to the refund maximums stated below.'
The refund maximums themselves, however, were not based on 'reasonable charges'. In fact they were set well below the typical cost for most operations.
In one case that formed part of Phillida Bunkle's complaint, Aetna client Derek Hunter needed an angioplasty. The 'refund maximum' for his operation was $2,100 per procedure, plus the cost of a night in hospital and other expenses. The full cost of the operation was $20,347, while Aetna contributed only $4,248, or 20% of Derek's total costs.
The Commerce Commission broadened its investigation to other Aetna policies and to similar misleading deals promoted by Southern Cross.
'The public were being ripped off and the insurance companies have been caught red-handed,' Phillida Bunkle said.
She's surprised that there hasn't been a criminal prosecution as a result of the finding.
'The insurance companies have agreed that they were involved in misleading conduct which breached the Fair Trading Act. They are lucky that they have got away with only having to reimburse patients, pay costs to the Commission and change their policies.
'There will be no compensation for patients who couldn't afford to have their operation when they realised that the insurance companies were not going to pay out on their promises. If anyone has died because of the insurance companies' behaviour, the companies will not be punished for it.
'The episode highlights the dangers of the Government's determination to privatise the health system. Insurance companies do not offer the care that the public system does and the public needs better protection than the insurance companies will provide,' Phillida Bunkle said.
ENDS
Alastair Thompson
Scoop Publisher
Alastair Thompson is the co-founder of Scoop. He is of Scottish and Irish extraction and from Wellington, New Zealand. Alastair has 24 years experience in the media, at the Dominion, National Business Review, North & South magazine, Straight Furrow newspaper and online since 1997. He is the winner of several journalism awards for business and investigative work.
Gordon Campbell: On Why We Can’t Survive Two More Years Of This
Office of the Privacy Commissioner: Christmas Is About Giving, But Don’t Give Up Your Privacy
The Rail Advocacy Collective: Chris Trotter - Running Us Off The Rails
Natural Hazards Commission: More Landslide Claims Than Ever; NHC Encourages Homeowners To Get Prepared
Te Ara Ahunga Ora Retirement Commission: What Does Retirement Really Look Like In 2024? New Research Highlights The Financial Struggles Of Over 65s
E tū: Minimum Wage Announcement “A Pay Cut For The Most Vulnerable”
NZ Government: Government Getting Local Government Back To Basics
