Celebrating 25 Years of Scoop
Aratere Ferry Grounding: Interislander Hits Back At Winston Peters' Claims
Bill Hickman, Journalist
KiwiRail has hit back at acting Prime Minister Winston Peters' claims that it covered up the cause of the grounding of the Aratere ferry.
The ferry ran aground on 21 June, with 47 people aboard - prompting inquiries from the transport agency, Maritime New Zealand and the Transport Accident Investigation Commission.
A leaked Interislander safety bulletin said a crew member accidentally executed a course change through the ship's auto pilot system soon after it left its Picton berth.
The crew then struggled for nearly a minute to regain control of the boat, but by then it was too late to stop the ferry crashing into the shore of Titoki Bay.
Earlier this week, New Zealand First tweeted a theory that a crew member left the boat on autopilot while they went for a cup of coffee.
This morning Winston Peters told RNZ that KiwiRail was not being up front about what occurred.
"We don't need a month-long enquiry or three or four month's while they try and do PR and damage control and cover their butts. Tell us the truth right here right now," Peters said.
When asked if he thought KiwiRail was covering up the real cause of the accident, Peters replied "I don't think it, I know it".
But Interislander operations general manager Duncan Roy rejected the suggestion.
He told RNZ the leaked document indicated the agency knew what had happened but it was up to the investigating bodies to determine the "how and why".
"I can state there's no cover up. We're engaging in the proper process and with a concentration on getting the facts and being fair and reasonable to our people as we go through this investigation," Roy said.
Labour Party transport spokesperson Tangi Utikere said Peters "delving" into the causes of the accident was extremely unhelpful.
He said the nation expected the investigations to be completed in a timely manner, but it was just as important their integrity was not compromised by political interference.
"What we did hear recently from KiwiRail is them going out saying that no one was on a coffee break as such. My read of that is they were forced to do that to quell some of the concerns that Winston Peters or the New Zealand First Party had put out into the public realm," Utikere said.
The Interislander safety bulletin showed a crew member prematurely selected a turn that should have taken the boat about a shore point called The Snout.
The error sent the boat directly into Titoki Bay - nearly a whole nautical mile ahead of The Snout.
John Riding has worked as a Maritime Consultant for nearly 30 years.
He said one of the lessons learned when the Aratere nearly ran aground in 2006 was that the ferries should always be under manual control while travelling through the Marlborough Sounds.
"To be on autopilot at Mabel Island is crazy and I can't believe for one second that's what Interislander's procedures say," Riding said.
"It shouldn't be happening, because Mabel Island is still a hazard, but after that the next hazard - only just around the corner - is at The Snout."
Maritime NZ lifted its detention notice on the Aratere on Wednesday 10 July.
Just before 2pm on Thursday the ferry limped into Wellington harbour escorted by a Wellington tug boat and under the watchful eye of harbour master Grant Nalder.
"Maritime New Zealand have put conditions on it and so have the harbour masters at either end," Nalder said.
"So you'll also see one of the Wellington tugs is just accompanying the vessel from when it gets into the channel, until it gets up to the berth."
KiwiRail is yet to confirm when the findings of the investigations into the accident will be released.
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
Gordon Campbell: On Luxon In The NATO Pressure Cooker
Greenpeace New Zealand: Govt’s ‘Climate Strategy’ As Useful As Teats On A Bull
The Future Is Rail: NZers Must Step Up To Protect Vital Cook Strait Rail Connection
Te Pāti Māori: Govt Determined To Make Aotearoa A Country Of Disposable Renters
NZ Labour Party: Megan Woods On The Five-Point Climate Strategy
Save Science: Science Under Threat - New Report Reveals Damaging Impact Of Govt’s Deep Cuts
Phil Smith, RNZ: Displacement, Drift, Layering And Conversion: The Changing Parliament
