Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
The Auckland Home That Lost $100,000 In 20 Years
Susan Edmunds, Money Correspondent
You might think that if you bought a house in Auckland 20 years ago and sold it this year, you would be guaranteed to make money.
But in a couple of recent sales, owners have lost money - and more than $100,000 in one case.
The reason? They were leasehold properties.
These are the kind of properties that often capture first-home buyers' attention, because they stand out among "for sale" listings due to their prices.
A one-bedroom waterfront apartment in Auckland, for example, is listed at the moment for less than $100,000. Or a three-bedroom home in Kohimarama with an asking price of $355,000.
One property in Papanui, Christchurch, sold last week for $100,000 with a CV of $580,000.
But while they might look like a bargain on the surface, there is a warning to buyers to take particular care.
When a property is leasehold, it usually means that the land under it does not come as part of the purchase. You're only buying the building, or part of it in the case of an apartment, and the right to put it on the land, for a fee.
The ground rent can run into tens of thousands of dollars a year and it usually increases in regular intervals, which can reduce the value of the property.
Ed McKnight, economist at Opes Partners, pointed to one property in Kohimarama, which sold for $320,000 earlier this year with a CV of $1.425 million. He said it had previously been bought for $330,000, so the value of the property had dropped by $10,000 over 19 years, while the wider Auckland area recorded an increase in sales price of almost 250 percent.
Another property in Parnell sold for $87,000 last week with a CV of $970,000. "It was previously bought for $205,235 back in June 2000. So over 24 years the property has gone down in value by 58 percent. Over the same period property values in Parnell have gone up by 335 percent.
"The property sold 91 percent below CV. But that's not a sign that the property was a good deal."
NZ Property Investors Federation spokesperson Matt Ball said leasehold properties could sometimes work for an investor.
"We do have members across the country who have leasehold properties as investments or rentals. The trick with this type of property is to pay close attention to the conditions of the lease and to be sure the numbers add up.
"For example, be aware of how frequently the ground rent is up for review and how much it could increase by, as this could significantly impact on the financial viability of your investment. With due care, a leasehold property can be a good investment.
Auckland Property Investors Association spokesperson Sarina Gibbon said it would be important that buyers had good legal and investment advice.
But McKnight said the ground rent could be "extraordinarily high", which made purchasing tough for investors as well as owner-occupiers.
"The issue with this is that the ground rent increases at the rate of land inflation. While the rental income increases at the rate of rental inflation.
"So your rental income might increase at 4.5 percent. Whereas the ground rent might increase by 7 percent per year. Over time this can severely erode the rental return. "
He said fewer than 1 percent of the properties sold in the last 12 months were leasehold.
"On top of this, sometimes the land and the house will transact at different times, which can skew the data. Because it can make it look like the same property is being bought and sold at wildly different prices."
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
NIWA: October Climate Summary - A Mild Month Overall, Very Wet For Much Of The South Island
Bill Bennett: I didn’t leave WordPress, WordPress left me
The Reserve Bank of NZ: Financial System Remains Resilient Amidst Economic Downturn
Entertainment Venues Association of NZ: New Ticketing Code To Enhance Confidence Of Ticket Buyers And Event Providers In New Zealand
RNZ Online: Aotearoa Has Multiple Clouds So Unique They Have Names
Organics Aotearoa NZ: Genetic Engineering Reforms Risk Making NZ An Outlier
