AUs Tertiary Update Vol 4 No 20
AUS
Tertiary Update Vol. 4 No. 20, 21 June
2001
*********************************************************************
In
our lead story this week…..
AUS STRESSES NEED FOR CRISIS
SUMMIT ON FUNDING
AUS is continuing discussions with the
New Zealand Vice-Chancellors’ Committee [NZVCC] on holding a
crisis summit to discuss the consequences for universities
of the Government's fee freeze deal. As the individual
university councils ponder their response to the deal, the
AUS Council agreed to hold no position on whether individual
tertiary institutions should accept the Government’s
budgetary offer, stating that the offer was unconscionable
and unacceptable. Neither option offered by the Government
was acceptable because it demonstrates a failure of the
Government to support the public tertiary education system.
Meanwhile, the NZVCC reports that dialogue between
universities and the Government is about to take place. At
the same time, the NZVCC repeated its advice to university
councils not to accept the deal, which it says will leave
universities with a funding shortfall of $24 million next
year, on top of an $18.3 million shortfall from last year’s
fees freeze deal. Councils have until 31 August to either
accept or reject the 2002 deal.
Also in Tertiary Update
this week:
An unfortunate example
Impact of
international students
We applaud the sentiments, but
where's the policy?
Now we are ten
Export boom has its
downside
European groups plan research push
AN
UNFORTUNATE EXAMPLE
The National Party leader, Jenny
Shipley -- in praising the performance of private training
providers -- has chosen an unfortunate example. Mrs Shipley
says private training providers ‘have helped to maintain
high performance standards amongst public tertiary
providers’ and cites the Careerlink College as an
outstanding example. AUS understands, however, that the
college was the subject of a recent complaint on the Holmes
Programme. Apparently, the Certificate in Bar Management
offered by the college is not recognised by the Licensing
Control Authority and so has limited use for job seekers.
IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS
A new report says
New Zealand must provide more guidance and support for
institutions that have international students on their rolls
if the country is ever to become a world leader in the field
of export education. The report -- "The Impact of
International Students on Domestic Students and Host
Institutions" -- is written by the head of the School of
Psychology at Victoria University of Wellington, Professor
Colleen Ward and is available at www.minedu.govt.nz. She
says the presence of international students, even in large
numbers, is not of itself enough to promote intercultural
interactions, develop friendships, and result in result in
international understanding. She says structures need to be
put in place to achieve this. The Minister in charge of
tertiary education, Steve Maharey, says the report has
important implications for the future direction of the New
Zealand export education market. He says he has asked the
Ministry of Education to look at how to provide greater
support and guidance for institutions hosting international
students, including developing examples of best practice.
WORTHY SENTIMENTS, BUT WHERE'S THE POLICY – AND THE
FUNDING?
Meanwhile, in an article in NZ Education Review
this week ("No quality without change"), AUS notes Minister
Steve Maharey’s statement that he wants a strategic approach
to export education that is "pitched at providing quality".
At the same time he acknowledges that "development of the
industry needs to be in harmony with the government’s agenda
with regard to strengthening the capabilities of
institutions at both secondary and tertiary levels". AUS
sees this as a principled and pragmatic approach to export
education, but we must note that Mr Maharey's statements
contradict current policy. It is no good the Government
promoting high quality university education for
international students, or domestic students come to that,
without a commitment to properly funding and supporting the
institutions and staff that are expected to provide it.
There is sophisticated and well-established international
competition for international students, with the USA, UK and
Australia being the main players. New Zealand universities
have to be seen to be of international standard, with high
quality research and teaching staff and facilities, if they
are to be serious contenders in the export education
industry.
NOW WE ARE TEN!
It's time for celebration.
On 1 July the Association of University Staff celebrates its
10th anniversary. AUS was formed in 1991 when the
Association of University Teachers (AUT) merged with the
University Technicians' Union (UTU). Earlier, in 1989, the
Association of New Zealand University Library Staff had
merged with AUT. The then President of AUS, Ruth Butterworth
-- who served between 1990 and 1991 -- summed up the
amalgamation of the various unions this way:
"The
Association has been signally strengthened by the addition
of technical staff, not simply by numerical growth or even
by the very considerable contribution made by the transfer
of UTU assets at both national and branch level; but much
more importantly, because this new Association has a greater
breadth in its expertise and approach to university problems
than had its predecessor".
The AUT was formed in 1923
and Emeritus Professor Nicholas Tarling has recently
completed a 75-year history of AUT and its successor AUS,
entitled "Professionals and Unionists".
WORLD WATCH
EXPORT BOOM HAS ITS DOWNSIDE
Staying with the
subject of export education, this time in the Australian
context…
a new report suggests that while the past
decade's push into international education has boosted the
income of universities, it has also changed the nature of
higher education. The report -- "The Comparative Performance
of Australia as a Knowledge Nation" -- says there has been a
skewing towards high revenue disciplines such as business
studies away from courses in engineering and science that
are important to the knowledge economy. It says the
proportion of overseas students doing research higher
degrees, engineering and science has halved since 1990.
Between 1990 and 1999 the number of domestic business
studies graduates rose by 107%, but international graduates
were up 729%. The report was commissioned by left-wing
think tank the Chifley Research Centre, and released by
Opposition Leader Kim Beazley last week. It was conducted
by Mark Considine of the University of Melbourne, Simon
Marginson of Monash, Peter Sheehan of the Victoria
University of Technology and Margarita Kumnick of Victoria
University of Technology. The report shows income from
international student fees at Australian universities went
from $136 million in 1990 to $686 million in 1999. But the
way it has changed the nature of higher education leads the
reports authors to conclude: "This is an unmistakable sign
that the international program is 'dumbing down'." Australia
now has the second highest proportion of international
higher education students in the OECD behind Switzerland.
EUROPEAN GROUPS PLAN RESEARCH PUSH
The European
Union and the European Investment Bank have signed an
agreement to promote research and technical innovation.
Under the agreement they will join forces to boost spending
on research and to use those funds more effectively. They
will establish a joint steering committee to co-ordinate
research support and avoid duplication of effort. An E.U.
official said science in Europe was on a par with the U.S.
and Japan, but lagged when it came to patenting and setting
up companies to develop products. This is put down to
Europe's relatively low spending on research. The 15
member countries of the European Union all invested
approximately 1.9 percent of their gross national products
in research in 1998, compared with 2.6 percent in the United
States and 3 percent in Japan. Current New Zealand spending
on research, as a percentage of GDP, is 0.64% for the public
sector and 0.34% for the private.
***************************************************************************
AUS
Tertiary Update is produced weekly on Thursdays and
distributed freely to members of the union and others. Back
issues are archived on the AUS website: