The Currency of the Islamic State
The Currency of the Islamic State: The Political and Symbolic Significance of an Economic Move
by
Ofir Winter
December 7,
2014
www.inss.org.il/index.aspx?id=4538&articleid=8289
On November 13, 2014 the Treasury of the Islamic State organization (IS) announced its intention to mint a first series of coins to be used in the territory under its control. For the leaders of IS, this move has both symbolic and economic meaning. Not only does the minting of coins reflect the group’s ambition to signal to its domestic public and its audience abroad that it is a sovereign state, not an organization, and to give this message iconographic expression. It also constitutes another stage in realizing the radical revolutionary vision of IS, which includes establishing an Islamic religious monetary regime, free from dependence on the international financial system. The IS monetary initiative combines wishful thinking with reality and is unlikely to be an economic threat to the West. Nevertheless, by issuing an independent currency, it is taking a symbolic step that could improve its prestige in the eyes of Muslim target audiences, strengthen the sense of governance it projects at home and abroad, and consolidate its hold on the territory under its control.
On November 13, 2014 the Treasury of the Islamic State organization (IS) announced its intention to mint a first series of coins to be used in the territory under its control. This is a direct order from the group’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. The first issue includes seven coins of differing values, with the respective metals and weights chosen in accordance with Islamic religious law: the dinar (4.25 grams of gold), the dirham (2.975 grams of silver), and the fils (0.496 grams of copper).
For the leaders of IS, this move has both symbolic and economic meaning. Not only does the minting of coins reflect the group’s ambition to signal to its domestic public and its audience abroad that it is a sovereign state, not an organization, and to give this message iconographic expression. It also constitutes another stage in realizing the radical revolutionary vision of IS, which includes establishing an Islamic religious monetary regime, free from dependence on the international financial system, and taking the lead in a global wave of repudiation of the US dollar.
Political and Symbolic
Significance
IS is a political entity that is
not recognized by sovereign countries and is struggling to
establish its authority among those who are supposed to see
themselves as its subjects. An independent currency will
support its claim to sovereignty, while continued use of the
currencies of states it aspires to dissolve weakens this
claim. Furthermore, the symbols on the coins provide an
additional layer for IS propaganda. They are intended to
assist in inculcating among target audiences at home and
abroad messages relating to IS identity, aspirations,
borders, and guiding policy ethos.
These symbols are divided into two main groups, and reflect the tension between the ambitious global objectives of IS and its inevitable need for cooperation on the part of the local population.
Symbols Expressing the Long Term Strategic
Vision
The five-dinar gold coin showing the five
continents and the copper ten-fils coin showing the Muslim
crescent reflect the extreme messages that are the basis of
IS ideology. The first image, as explained in official
publications, symbolizes the promise that according to
tradition God gave to the Prophet Muhammad, namely, that his
nation would rule over territory from the eastern to the
western ends of the earth. The Muslim crescent, which
represents the Hijri calendar and is displayed on the flags
of Muslim countries in the Middle East, North Africa, and
Southeast Asia, is a Muslim symbol that speaks to the hearts
of the global target audience that IS purports to
represent.
A spear and shield appear on the silver one-dirham coin, while the ten-dirham coin shows the al-Aqsa mosque. According to official publications, the weapons symbolize jihad for God, that is, the violent struggle through which IS will realize its territorial ambitions. The choice of the mosque in Jerusalem that is the third holiest site in Islam shows that it is a future target for conquest by IS. This choice bespeaks the vitality of the ethos of the struggle to liberate Jerusalem as a source of national religious legitimacy. It also implies that the propaganda appeal of the struggle to liberate al-Aqsa exceeds even that of the struggle to liberate Mecca and Medina, sites that according to Islamic dogma are holier.
Symbols with an
Iraqi-Syrian Local Character
The three other coins
have symbols with a particularist hue, which on the face of
it contradicts the global message of IS. They were designed
with the current borders in mind and inspired by
characteristically Iraqi and Syrian symbols in order to
market the new regime’s revolutionary doctrine to the
public in Iraq and Syria through a recognizable and accepted
symbolic prism. For example, the twenty-fils copper coin has
an engraving with three palm trees. This tree is considered
the national symbol of Iraq and has appeared over the years
on many of its coins. The five-dirham silver coin shows a
while lighthouse in Damascus, through which, according to a
prophetic tradition glorifying the Islamic mission of Syria,
at the end of days, Issa ibn Mariam (Jesus) will return to
earth in order to defeat the dajjal (the false messiah). A
one-dinar gold coin bears an illustration of wheat stalks, a
traditional symbol of economic growth, which was also used
by the regimes in Iraq and Syria.
Economic
Significance
IS has also explained its minting
of coins as an economic step with strategic pretensions. Its
spokesmen have noted three main advantages of the
move.
Conversion of Forbidden Coins into Permitted
Coins
In accordance with the Salafist doctrine of IS,
for the first time since the end of the Ottoman caliphate,
the issuing of Islamic coins will create a monetary system
that is in keeping with the dictates of Islamic law, which
rejects the use of bills, money changing, bond trading, and
usury. According to IS ideology, the modern global economy
relies on “worthless” paper currency and is responsible
for periods of inflation, depression, and crisis. On the
other hand, the use of gold, silver, and copper coins, which
have an intrinsic value, will provide the IS economy with
stability, immunity, and credibility and give the citizens
confidence that their money will not lose its value because
of a possible drop in exchange rates.
Repudiation of
Economic Dependence on the West
According to the
official announcement by IS, the new currency will enable it
to break away from the “tyrannical financial system
imposed on the Muslims, which has been a factor in enslaving
and impoverishing them, in wasting the resources of the
Islamic ummah, and in making it easy prey for the Jews and
Crusaders.” Minting of the coins has been described as a
step to escape the economic hegemony imposed by the United
States and the “despicable band of Jews” in the World
Bank and the International Monetary Fund, who “control the
global financial markets.” According to this conspiracy
theory, the United States currently enjoys a monopoly over
production of oil, “with which God graced the Muslim
ummah.” It is imposing use of the dollar as the sole
currency for determining the oil rate in order to steal the
Muslims’ money and resources and to finance its economy at
their expense. Pure metal coins will liberate the Islamic
caliphate from subordination to the dollar economy because
it will not need recognition from the World Bank or the
International Monetary Fund and will be difficult to impose
sanctions on it.
Renewing Islam’s Glorious
Days
IS believes that issuing its own coins will
hasten the collapse of the US economy and lead to the
decline of the United States as a global power and the rise
of the Islamic caliphate. It feels that the move will
encourage other oppressed countries to follow in its
footsteps, i.e., to liberate their currencies from the
humiliating Western hegemony and achieve financial
independence. IS leaders believe that this chain reaction
will cause the rapid collapse of “the economy of colored
bills” and the creation of “a true economy of
production,” which will change the existing hierarchy
among the countries of the world and grant the Muslims
superiority over the infidels.
Conclusion and
Recommendations
The IS monetary initiative
combines wishful thinking with reality and is unlikely to be
an economic threat to the West. Nevertheless, by issuing an
independent currency, it is taking a symbolic step that
could improve its prestige in the eyes of Muslim target
audiences, strengthen the sense of governance it projects at
home and abroad, and consolidate its hold on the territory
under its control. The plan indicates that for IS,
conquering the old countries and destroying their
institutions and frameworks is not enough, and that it will
dedicate a portion of its resources to long term processes
of state building and the establishment of new symbols and
mechanisms of government. Various reports show that IS has
purchased gold, silver, and copper with the idea of
implementing the minting project.
IS has internalized that its political revolutionary enterprise, which began in the mosques and has continued in the battlefield, must also focus on mobilizing the loyalty of residents of the conquered territories, inter alia, through their purses. Those fighting against its ambition to realize its vision must internalize this, and the international community would do well to intensify economic pressure on IS. To this end, it should first and foremost continue attacks against the oil trade, which provides IS with liquid capital for its activities, including acquisition of the metals needed for minting coins. At the same time, the international community must begin to formulate a plan to reconstruct Iraq and Syria with the goals of ensuring a positive economic outlook for their impoverished populations and preventing them from being led astray by radical Islam.
ENDS