U.S. Withdrawal From Afghanistan: 1989 Vs. 2021
BANGKOK, Thailand -- President Biden's announced
withdrawal from
Afghanistan will be the second time since
1989 that the U.S. retreats
from that country -- and
twice after years of boosting war but losing
control over
Islamist insurgents.
When previously enthusiastic,
then-Senator Joe Biden arrived in Kabul
in January 2002
in response to 9/11, he voiced a gung-ho call for
U.S.
military involvement.
"Make it clear, I'm not
talking about [international] peace keepers.
I'm not
talking about [U.N.] blue helmets. I'm talking about
people
who shoot and kill people," the senator told
reporters on January 12,
2002, standing in front of the
embassy in a cold, clear, bone-dry
winter
breeze.
"I'm talking about people who are a bunch of
bad asses who will come
in here with guns, and understand
that they don't have to check with
anybody before they
return fire.
"I am talking about pursuers. I'm talking
about a tough, rough,
militarily controlled -- no
'sign-off by' -- no diplomatic requirement
to determine
whether they can return fire.
"If we have these guys
here, I want them to be able to return fire or
initiate
fire.
"I ain't talking about peace, love and
brotherhood," said Mr. Biden,
who was also chairman of
the Foreign Relations Committee.
"Unless we are part
of a multinational effort to provide for the
rudimentary
needs in this country of basic housing, water being
able
to flow, toilets able to flush, sewers able to flow,
traffic lights
able to turn on, it's very, very
difficult...for government to be able
to
function.
"We are not talking about rebuilding Paris.
This is not the Marshall
Plan after World War
Two.
"It is in our naked self-interest," Mr. Biden said.
A few months earlier in 2001, U.S. forces had
invaded to oust the
Taliban and neutralize Al Qaeda
leader Osama bin Laden.
The Americans were surprised
when they discovered eerie artifacts
silently entombed in
the hulking, concrete U.S. Embassy in Kabul.
U.S.
documents, the diplomats' hurriedly abandoned half-smoked
cigars,
and thick spider webs lay inside.
The
American Embassy's worried diplomats had fled in a snowstorm
12
years earlier in January 1989 while the Soviet Union
withdrew the last
of its 115,000 Red Army
troops.
The Kremlin's 10 years of unwinnable war
killed an estimated one
million people on all
sides.
When Moscow abandoned the vulnerable Afghan
regime to its doom,
Americans feared their own U.S.-armed
"holy warrior" mujahideen
guerrillas would turn the
Afghan capital into a bloodbath.
The new Biden
withdrawal -- scheduled before September 11 --
could
benefit from lessons learned during that 1989
retreat by the Soviets
and Americans.
"My feeling
is that it will become very unsafe in Kabul after
the
Soviets leave, although it appears placid at the
moment," the U.S.
Embassy's then-Political Officer James
Schumaker told us while he was
evacuating Afghanistan on
January 30, 1989.
U.S. Marine guards meanwhile
solemnly folded the embassy's Stars and
Stripes in a
tight triangular bundle to take with them.
The night
before, the handful of Marines drank as much as they
could
of the embassy's stash of alcohol.
"We are
honored to have served and helped the Afghan people
toward
peace and freedom," then-Charge d’Affaires John
Glassman said in a
farewell speech.
"We will be back as soon as the conflict is over."
When heavy
snowfall blocked the embassy's air evacuation later
that
day, Glassman joked:
"Send in Rambo! Send in
the Delta Force! I have a Harley Davidson
parked under
the U.S. Embassy, so nothing is going to stop me
from
getting out of Afghanistan.
"If I can't fly
out today, I'll ride right through 'mooj'
[mujahideen]
territory and through the Khyber Pass to
Pakistan. Every biker in
America will cheer me."
It
would have been an awesome sight, Mr. Glassman on a
chopper
hurtling down the road, east through
Jalalabad.
It didn't happen.
The following
day, their chartered Indian Airlines flight arrived
from
New Delhi and ferried the last U.S. diplomats,
Marines and other staff
to India.
The embassy
abandoned its fleet of black official
vehicles,
intentionally disabled so no one could drive
them.
The embassy's doors were locked, to be guarded
by Washington's enemy,
the Soviet-backed Afghan Marxist
regime.
Years passed. Afghans fought greedy civil wars, destroying much of Kabul.
Regimes changed.
The tan-colored embassy eventually suffered scars from failed break-ins.
Heavy gunfire damaged the gray metal gate along the street.
Apparently, no one had gained access to the embassy since it was locked in 1989.
Most other embassies had also shut down, including the Soviet Union's.
In November 2001, I
approached the U.S. embassy's thick,
bullet-shattered
glass front door, where someone had placed a vinyl
record
album attached to thick electric wires, resembling
a
booby-trap.
The album was "Rejuvenation" by The Meters, a funk band.
The wires were a ruse.
Next to the embassy, two burnt U.S. automobiles lay charred.
One appeared to be a Lincoln Continental or a
Cadillac, most likely
used by the ambassador.
The other blackened vehicle was a station wagon.
The
post-9/11 U.S. invasion soon brought fresh American
diplomats who
officially re-opened the dirt-encrusted
embassy on December 17, 2001
after searching for
explosives.
Walking with them, through spacious rooms
and empty hallways, felt
like strolling into a lost
world.
In the American ambassador's musty office, his
black, rubbery gas mask
hung next to a dust-covered
record player.
Then-Secretary of State George Shultz's
framed portrait grinned on the
ambassador's
wall.
On a coffee table, a 1988 Department of State
"Salary Chart" lay open
next to a colorful booklet
describing how to decorate "Diplomatic
Reception
Rooms".
A gray filing cabinet displayed metal drawers
haphazardly yanked and
extended, after priority folders
were quickly extracted.
Half-drunk cans of Coca-Cola, Fanta and 7-Up stood on tables in other rooms.
In the
basement's snack bar, a menu offered hamburgers and
other
American fast food.
Filthy red-and-white
checkered tablecloths gave a cheerful, albeit
mummified
look to the snack bar which displayed peeling wall paper,
a
dangling 1989 calendar, warped floors, and a ceiling
marred by fallen
tiles.
Upstairs in the deputy
chief of mission's office, documents included a
Defense
Intelligence Agency's "Warsaw Pact Ground Forces
Equipment
Identification Guide to Armored Fighting
Vehicles."
A pamphlet from the Bureau of Diplomatic
Security lay on a shelf near
other documents stamped
UNCLASSIFIED.
Walls displayed maps of Afghanistan. Red
circles marked Soviet
military sites during the Kremlin's
1979-1989 occupation.
In the embassy's lobby, a
wrinkled copy of Afghanistan's
government-controlled
Kabul Times newspaper lay on the floor,
trumpeting news
about Soviet-installed Afghan President
Najibullah.
The U.S. expected Mr. Najibullah would be
overthrown six months after
Moscow's withdrawal finished
on February 15, 1989.
Mr. Najibullah, a fearsome
barrel-chested authoritarian, remained in
power until
1992.
Then some of his army, led by warlord General
Abdul Rashid Dostum up
north in Mazar-i-Sharif,
mutinied.
General Dostum joined the insurgents and
helped enable U.S.-backed
Islamist guerrillas to finally
seize Kabul.
Najibullah meanwhile waited too long before trying to escape.
Unable to reach the airport, he retreated to the Indian Embassy until 1996.
Victorious Taliban seized and hung Mr.
Najibullah in the street from a
lamp post, with two
cigarettes dangling from his dead nostrils.
Today, Mr.
Biden might also learn a grim lesson from a poem written
by
President Najibullah:
"What has war brought
them?
Grave instead of shelter.
Shroud instead of
clothes.
Bullet in the stomach instead of
food."
***
Richard S. Ehrlich traveled across
Afghanistan in 1972, and reported
from Afghanistan during
the Soviet Union's 1979-1989 war and
withdrawal, the
U.S.-backed mujahideen victory in 1992, and the
U.S.
invasion during November 2001 through January 2002.
Excerpts from his
new nonfiction book, "Rituals. Killers.
Wars. & Sex. -- Tibet, India,
Nepal, Laos, Vietnam,
Afghanistan, Sri Lanka & New York" are
available
at
https://asia-correspondent.tumblr.com