Richard Prebble's Letter from Wellington 9/10/00
Richard Prebble's Letter from Wellington Monday, 09 October 2000
Richard Poole's full page advertisement has resulted in frenzied coalition attacks. Labour's polling says that the loss of skilled New Zealanders is an issue deeply worrying the electorate. Helen Clark has adopted her usual crisis management strategy: playing the man and not the ball.
The Migration Facts
Helen Clark said on the
Holmes show, "fewer people left in the year to August this
year than last year". If you look at net migration she is
right. The appointment of Winston Peters saw a huge
increase in emigrating New Zealanders, and a halt in
immigration. Ergo, net migration, 1997: 14,491; 1998: -2842;
1999: -11,124; 2000: -10,032. But the election of the
coalition has seen emigration figures rise. The absolute
number of New Zealanders leaving is at an all time record,
1997: 58,615; 1998: 61,996; 1999: 68,003; 2000: 72,083.
Loss Of Skill
We have had migration peaks before. In the
early 1980's, under Sir Robert, large numbers of New
Zealanders left. What is new is who is leaving,
professionals and skilled people. Last year, 19,235 skilled
New Zealand left and 13,739 skilled immigrants arrived - a
net lose of -5,496 people. But it's worse. We are losing
trained doctors while those replacing them struggle to have
their qualifications recognised. (ACT MP, Ken Shirley, has a
private members Bill before the House aiming to make the
recognition of qualifications process more efficient).
After all, we are short of doctors, not taxi drivers.
ACT's Issue
ACT leads on the issue because it is the
most important issue facing the country. ACT is constantly
reviewing immigration figures and will relay news on the
trends in future speeches.
Is Clark Losing Control?
The ferocity and frequencies of Helen Clark's personal
attacks suggest she may be under immense stress trying to
manage the coalition. A Senior Labour Cabinet minister said
on the dinner circuit, "We can manage the Alliance
Ministers, what we can not control are the incompetents they
insist on hiring in their offices." Prophetic words. If Tony
Simpson had not called Richard Poole a "half-wit", would
Poole have organised the fullpage ad? If Jim Anderton had
not invited himself to a Roundtable meeting, and then called
New Zealand's twenty largest businesses the cause of the
"largest single explosion in welfare dependency ever", would
Roger Kerr have concluded that the only way to talk to the
Government was through the media. If Clark and Cullen had
invited the Head of the Roundtable to the October dialogue,
would the ad have appeared?
GST Receipts
The Finance
Minister keeps spinning that the fall in business confidence
is not justified by citing GST receipts. In reality, the
returns for July and August are down a massive 6.8%. Someone
also needs to explain provisional tax to Michael Cullen.
This year's tax is based on last year - a good year. Next
year's will be based on this year- a bad year. Firms will
also receive credits for the extra tax they paid - a fiscal
double whammy is coming. Accountants tell ACT they have
never seen such aggressive tax planning by New Zealanders
determined not to pay the coalition's 39 cent envy tax.
Cullen won't know about this until provisional returns are
filed next April. He will get a shock, a $300 million
shock.
But The Socialists Are Happy
In the last 6
months Telecom has dropped form $9.60 to $5.40. Its market
capital has fallen from $16.85 billion to $9.47 billion and
shareholders have lost $7.4 billion. It is fair to assume
that Kiwis own half of Telecom (either directly through
savings or indirectly through pension funds and super
schemes). This means Kiwis have had $3.7 billion wiped from
their savings. That's about $1,000 each. The Government
believes their telecommunications inquiry will save
consumers $300 - $400 million per year. In the last five
days Telecom has fallen from $6.25 to $5.40. That has wiped
off $1.5 billion in market capital. If half the loss is
borne by domestic savers, this means a loss of $750 million,
almost twice the inquiry's touted long run consumer
savings.
MP Pay Rise
Another shock will be the Higher
Salaries Commission's decision on MP pay rates. The media
thought Michael Cullen's remarks about pay restraint were
directed at Dr Brash's pay. It was really directed at the
Commission reviewing MPs salaries. The criteria used is set
out in law, and if applied correctly, could see a 9.5 per
cent pay rise for MPs! Having put the Employment Relations
Act in place, there is now nothing to stop such a pay shock
bulleting through the economy.
Stagflation
The Letter
(with all due modesty) would like to point out that it was
first (18/09/00) to predict stagflation. ACT Chief of Staff,
Chris Milne, revived the term (the Letter is receiving
e-mails from younger readers asking what it means). Cullen
is adamant it won't happen. The Letter points out it has.
The economy is in recession and inflation is rising. Result,
stagflation.
ERA Equals Complexity
All hiring is
still suspended as the Parliamentary Commission struggles to
put together an employment contract that meets the
Employment Relations Act.
The old collective contracts are 20 pages. The new one will be over 50. It is the Employment Relations Act's compliance costs that will prove to be the main problem. It will cost millions to convert the 600,000 verbal employment contracts to writing.
Reaction To
Chapple Report
The Chapple report that shows the gaps
are closing, not widening, is causing huge ripples in the
civil service. Predictably, Te Puni Kokiri, has produced a
report denying it (the report is so bad the departments
decided not to publish it). The grievance industry is in a
complete tizz. They can't fault Chapple's research and their
lucrative incomes are at risk.