Richard Prebble's Letter from Wellington
Richard Prebble's
Letter from Wellington
Monday, 25
February 2002
Petrol Tax Increase
The Letter understands Helen Clark tomorrow will announce a $2b spending package to complete Auckland's motorways. Mayor John Banks has got everything he wants.
The government is also expected to hike the tax on petrol by four cents-a-litre - allegedly to pay for the new motorways. But the government already collects $1.6 billion from motorists and spends just $550 million on roads. The only connection between the 4 cents and transport is that it will help pay for Tuku's BMW.
The spending package won't work unless the real problem is tackled. It's not money but planning delays that are holding up Auckland's motorways. The Resource Management Act has made it virtually impossible to build a road when there are serious objectors.
The Grafton Gully motorway extension will take three years to build but planning approval has taken six years. At this rate, a proposed motorway extension through Helen Clark's electorate will never get approval. What's really needed is a re-write of the RMA. The new petrol tax is a broken promise. Labour's pledge card said the only tax increase would be the 39 cent top rate of income tax.
Tax Revenue
The government's tax revenue is well ahead of forecast this year - showing they don't need the extra four cent petrol tax. Dr Cullen claims the extra revenue is from the higher top rate of income tax. But Treasury computers can't tell how much revenue is due to the rise in the top tax rate. Theoretically, it should produce $300 million a year.
The Letter sticks to its assertion that the higher top rate has produced no extra revenue. Tax consultants confirm that tax planning is a huge growth industry. Leading tax accountants have told the Letter they have no clients paying 39 cents. So who is paying the extra tax?
Wage workers - Labour's traditional support base. Households earning less than $40,000, who don't qualify for a community services card or a state house, whose children are zoned to failure schools, are paying the extra tax through inflation.
ACT's polling shows there's a revolt starting among Labour's "hard-working class" supporters - those Mike Moore called the battlers. The government has done nothing for this group except to place gang members in state houses in their street, ruining the neighbourhood.
Queen Bashing and Other
Lines
Helen Clark has attacked the NZ Herald for accurately reporting her cheap shot at the Queen. The Letter thinks the Herald should also have critically covered Clark's speech in London. It's a fantasy re-write of history. Some examples: "In the mid-1990s the (NZ) economy marked time". In fact, the economy grew at up to 5.8 percent p.a. - more than twice the current rate. And: "We took office after 15 years of neo-liberalism". What! Winston Peters and Bill Birch were neo-liberals?
Clark then
claimed that most business people don't want lower taxes and
less red tape. You can only say that overseas. The Prime
Minister wasn't available to welcome the Queen because she
wanted to electioneer. (See
Trouble at
Court The leaking of the internet viewing habits
of six judges is due to staff anger in the Courts
Department. Not only have several court staff lost their
jobs for viewing exactly the same kind of material that the
judges did, but staff are also angry at collusion between
their union - the PSA - and politically-correct management.
Most court staff have left the PSA. Management's response
has been to sign a new wage contract that favours PSA
members by having an earlier start date. While it's illegal
to discriminate against union members, it's lawful to
discriminate against non-union staff. No private employer
would be silly enough to favour union members - unlike the
politically-correct brigade. So there's war within the
courts department. Last week we learned about the porn. Now
we've heard about the judges' $72,000 weekend conference.
The Letter expects the leaks to continue. Parole and
Justice The government's admission that 40 percent
of those on parole breach their parole conditions, couldn't
have come at a worse time for the coalition. Parliamentary
questions by ACT's Stephen Franks have revealed parole is a
joke. Most parolees are not supervised. Re-offending rates
are horrendous. Under the new Sentencing and Parole Reform
Bill, most offenders will be released from jail after
serving just one-third of their sentence, to parole that
won't be properly supervised, and will re-offend within 12
months. This will be an election issue and it's one that ACT
owns. Shop Trading Bill Rodney Hide's Shop
Trading Bill is causing the two old parties huge anxiety.
Neither party knows how their MPs will vote on the issue.
Some Labour MPs gave passionate speeches about how opening
at Easter would exploit workers but then said retailers in
their electorates should be able to open if a cruise ship
was in port. The debate on clause one - which usually
takes an hour - lasted all Wednesday night, as neither the
National or Labour whip was willing to find out who had the
numbers in a vote. The only MPs who know what they think are
the Alliance - who are united in opposing freedom - and ACT
who are equally united in supporting freedom. The
Remarkable Mrs Raukawa-Tait Merepeka
Raukawa-Tait's decision to stand for Christian Heritage came
as a surprise to Peter Dunne who thought she'd agreed to
stand for his United Future Party. Her appointment as
deputy-leader of Christian Heritage also surprised many
party members. Inside the party, homosexuality is regarded
as evil and their new deputy-leader's liberal views are seen
as what's wrong with society. Peter Dunne's problem is that
he is now leading a religious party that wants the
"Christian" vote - about 4 percent of the electorate - but
he doesn't want his constituents in Ohariu-Belmont to
know. Ends