Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Decision To Remove Luxon Artwork From Trade Me 'Weird' - Artist
Ashleigh McCaull, Journalist
The artist behind a painting depicting Christopher Luxon in a fleshy tunnel says he is genuinely surprised Trade Me pulled it from their website.
Artist Josh Drummond who painted the portrait was raising funds for Kiwipal (The Kiwi Trust for Palestinian Children's Relief) and Rainbow Youth.
He said the removal from Trade Me did not add up.
"I've done two satirical, political auctions before, they were quite a long time ago now but they were really well received and the first one was a pretty awful portrait of Michael Laws and Trade Me loved it. At the time they emailed me and said 'can we add this to cool auctions' and it did really well because of that," Drummond said.
Journalist David Farrier first reported on the Luxon artwork last week on his website Webworm.
No-one from Trade Me was available for an interview but in a statement James Ryan from Policy and Compliance said the artwork breached its guidelines.
"We don't allow listings that feature high profile politicians with material of a suggestive nature and/or graphic iconography. For example, in the past we have removed listings relating to Jacinda Ardern. This is not a new policy.
"To be clear, this is the only reason that the listing was removed. It had nothing to do with political interference or the causes the listing supported. Trade Me allows fundraising for victims of war and also organisations that support our rainbow community here in Aotearoa New Zealand."
But in a response to Drummond, Trade Me said the work was removed because it had concerns it was "risky for buyers or against the family friendly spirit of the community".
Drummond did not think the response was good enough.
"I just thought it was weird because the painting isn't meant to be sexually suggestive and graphic, it could mean pretty much anything. The common meaning of graphic would probably be synonymous with sexually suggestive or sexually explicit so I'm assuming that's what they mean but the painting isn't either of those things and it's not intended to be," Drummond said.
He explained the meaning of the painting had a few layers to it and was inspired by the official portrait of King Charles III.
"Basically it was meant to be what if that portrait was a little bit ghastlier. The original idea was to have Luxon's head popping out from a wall of flesh which was the meaning a lot of people got from that King Charles portrait... I found that the photo reference I used for Luxon wasn't working with that wall of flesh idea so I was like: 'Oh I'll make it more of a tunnel'," Drummond said.
Trade Me's reasoning for removing his artwork came across as hypocritical based on the types of items he found on its website, including Nazi regalia.
"Some people on Bluesky found an actual Nazi rifle... stuff that's still up includes a whole tonne of white supremacist and Nazi memorabilia. One of the most noticeable things there was a Nazi camp sign, so a sign in German warning about an electric fence."
He said there was a whole bunch of nude art including one a user of Reddit found of an underage girl by an Australian artist.
He also noted there was MAGA - Make Ardern Go Away caps, Moa Bones and more recently, Luxon on a coffee mug with an offensive caption on it.
Any funds which were put towards the work were refunded.
The Prime Minister's Office declined to comment on the artwork.
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
Gordon Campbell: Gordon Campbell On The Government’s Ongoing Ferries Disaster 
Common Grace Aotearoa: Reaction To The Emissions Reduction Plan From The Don’t Subsidise Pollution Campaign
NZ Government: New Ferries Will Ensure Safe, Resilient Connection
Sanctuary Community Organic Garden Mahi Whenua Inc: Charitable Society Vs Crown Legal Case Has Implications For Property Rights In NZ
Stand Tū Māia: Stand Tū Māia Sues Children’s Ministry For Breach Of Contract
Environmental Defence Society: Not Too Late To Fix Controversial Fast-track Approvals Bill
Transparency International NZ: Anti-Corruption Day 2024 - Monday 9 December 2024 Is International Anti-Corruption Day
