Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Darleen Tana Wants More Time After Greens Vote To Waka-Jump Her
Anneke Smith, Political reporter
One of Darleen Tana's lawyers says the former Green MP wants the party to wait for a 'definitive' court ruling before booting her out of Parliament.
The Green Party's membership unanimously decided to invoke the waka-jumping legislation at a special general meeting last night.
Tana's lawyer Sharyn Green told Midday Report her client would prefer the party waited until the outcome of her upcoming appeal.
"Ms Tana has an appeal pending to the Court of Appeal... her obvious reaction is that she would prefer it if the Green Party would wait till the outcome of the appeal."
The Greens co-leaders have already written to the Speaker Gerry Brownlee who will make the final call on whether or not the threshold of affecting "the proportionality" of Parliament has been met.
Tana's lawyer said it was not appropriate this step had been taken, given the pending legal process had not run its full course.
"She was contesting that she was ousted from the Green Party by her own hand, that she was pushed, and that was the claim that was made before the High Court, that she was unlawfully pushed out of the Green Party," she said.
"So if you accept that that is an issue, whether she was pushed out of the Greens or whether she resigned, as has been reported, then I would have thought as a lawyer and Ms Tana obviously thinks as the applicant in front of the Court of Appeal that the Greens should wait until there has been a ruling definitively as to whether she resigned as they claimed or whether she was pushed."
Last month's High Court decision found the party's decision to commission an independent investigation into Tana's knowledge of migrant exploitation at her husband's business had been "constitutionally authorised".
"The inquiry was neither unreasonable nor unfair, and certainly not in the administrative law sense that might justify declarations by way of judicial review," Justice Johnstone found.
ACT Party leader David Seymour said the Green Party's decision to use the party-hopping legislation was a sad day for democracy.
"Regardless of what you think of Darleen Tana or the Green Party, it's important that only the voters can remove a representative from Parliament.
"Once you allow one group of members of Parliament to strip the rights of another member of Parliament then you remove the conscience of MPs speaking on behalf of New Zealanders and that is not a place that we want to go."
The waka-jumping law has not been used since 2003, when the ACT Party expelled Donna Awatere Huata over allegations of fraud.
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
Gordon Campbell: Gordon Campbell On The Folly Of Making Apologies In A Social Vacuum.
Cooper Legal: Censorship Is Alive And Well In New Zealand
NZ Government: NZ Signs Trade Deal With Costa Rica, Iceland And Switzerland
Forest And Bird: Modernisation Of Conservation System Must Focus On Improving Conservation
NZCTU: Uniformed Defence Force Should Not Be Used As Strike Breakers
MetService: Damp Start To Canterbury Anniversary Weekend; Wet Start For Coldplay Fans In Auckland
RNZ: Senior Lawyers Call For Treaty Principles Bill To Be Abandoned
