Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Government Reverses Decision To Bar Journalist From Abuse Apology At Parliament
Giles Dexter, Political Reporter
An investigative journalist who was barred from attending the national apology to survivors of abuse in care has now been granted accreditation.
Parliament's speaker has now granted temporary Press Gallery accreditation to journalist Aaron Smale for Tuesday's apology for abuse in care. He must, however, be accompanied by a Newsroom reporter at all times.
It follows significant backlash from survivors and advocates to the initial decision.
Smale has covered abuse in care, and the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the abuse, for eight years. His work has appeared in multiple publications and websites, including Newsroom, Newshub, the Listener, the Spinoff, and RNZ.
Last week, speaker Gerry Brownlee declined an application from Newsroom for Smale to report on the apology.
Parliament's Press Gallery gallery had asked for an explanation, as a refusal was quite rare, especially when a reporter met the gallery's criteria for accreditation.
It was told the application was declined, with the speaker citing Smale's conduct on a prior occasion.
On Monday afternoon, the press gallery wrote to the speaker, requesting a more fulsome explanation.
In an about-turn, the speaker approved the application.
The initial decision to decline Smale's application was met with backlash by survivor groups and advocates, as well as politicians and Newsroom itself.
At a media conference at Parliament in July, Smale and the Prime Minister had an exchange over the government's law and order policies, and whether the Prime Minister would acknowledge the link between abuse and gang membership.
According to Newsroom, Smale had also attended a media event at a youth justice facility in Palmerston North, and pressed children's minister Karen Chhour over whether it had been appropriate to associate the memory of the Māori Battalion with the new youth justice programme.
"The Beehive was in touch with us to say they believed he had been too forceful and too rude, in their view, in those two occasions," Newsroom's co-editor Tim Murphy told Nine to Noon.
Murphy said that Smale had conceded he had pushed the children's minister a bit far.
"But the one in Parliament, he was asking specific questions and kept asking them of the Prime Minister and I think that became irritating to the Prime Minister," Murphy said.
Describing Smale as "the most informed, possibly, probably of all New Zealand journalists" on the issue of abuse in state care institutions, Murphy said political discomfort should not be a reason to exclude Smale, and the ban should not stand.
"He should be there, and he should be asking questions, because he'll know more than virtually everybody else who could be," he said.
Murphy said Smale's intention for his coverage of the apology itself was to write an observational piece through the eyes of survivors, and he was not intending to "get into a grilling."
The Royal Commission Forum, an advisory group to the commission, said denying Smale accreditation was "profoundly concerning" and a damaging decision in the lead-up to the apology.
The Green Party said it was alarmed by the move, and said it set a dangerous precedent.
"As a society that values the role of the fourth estate, we should value the work of journalists like Aaron, because it helps us take a critical look at where we have gone wrong and how we may move forward," said the Greens' media and communications spokesperson Hūhana Lyndon.
"Barring a leading journalist from an important event like this speaks to this Government's lack of accountability. It is something we might expect in Putin's Russia, not 21st century Aotearoa New Zealand."
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
Gordon Campbell: On Abortion’s Role In The US Election
Green Party: Govt Move To Exclude Journalist Risks Chilling Effect
Taupo Neighbourhood Support: Secure Your Vehicle With Anti-theft Screws
Te Kāhui Tika Tangata Human Rights Commission: Commission Calls For The Promise Of Te Tiriti O Waitangi To Be Honoured
West Coast Emergency Management: Local State Of Emergency Declared for the Southern ward of Westland District
NZ Defence Force: NZDF Honours Last Māori Battalion Warrior, Sir Robert Nairn Gillies KNZM
The Treasury: Interim Financial Statements Of The NZ Govt For The Three Months Ended 30 September 2024
