Integrity in Science: Implications for the Climate
Sir Peter Gluckman’s public speech - Integrity in
Science: Implications for the Climate Change Debate
9 June 2010 at Victoria University of Wellington
Sir Peter Gluckman is delivering a speech on 9 June as part of The Institute of Political Studies series on Key Policy Challenges Facing New Zealand.
“Contemporary science has become dominated by the study of complex systems. But such science often is associated with levels of uncertainty and is based on concepts of probability.
In the case of climate change, despite this uncertainty, policy judgements need to be made so as to mitigate against and adapt to predicted scenarios.
While there is a very high
level of consensus amongst climate scientists as to the
nature of climate change and its anthropogenic
underpinnings, there is a high level of denial
and
scepticism in the broader community. While scepticism is
inherent in a robust self-correcting scientific process,
denialism is different, but it is not a unitary phenomenon.
Comparable situations have included the arguments over
tobacco and cancer, evolution and creation and the
HIV-denial movement.
Further, as has been the case in
other issues of this nature, there are a variety of motives
underlying these different positions and thus responses
arising.
The reasons for this discord are multiple and
are the topic of this presentation with a focus on climate
change.
The consequences present a challenge both to the
science system and to how science and society will continue
to interact”.
ENDS