Fireworks Dangerous In More Ways Than One
Playing with a fireworks sparkler for just eight minutes is the equivalent of breathing a day’s air pollution and breaches safe levels, new research shows.
Scientists measure air quality by the
amount of particulate matter, known as PM10, in the air as
micrograms per unit volume of air (g m-3), basically a
cubic metre of air. Most people breathe in around 11 cubic
metres of air per day. New Zealand guidelines state that the
daily level of g m-3 cannot be over 50.
Most previous
studies of pollution generated by fireworks have focused on
professional large-scale events but in New Zealand, personal
fireworks are the most common form of celebration during Guy
Fawkes.
To better understand the contribution of
fireworks on local air quality, ambient PM10 sampling was
conducted in the 10 days surrounding Guy Fawkes in Auckland
in 2019. Researchers used Auckland City Council air quality
monitoring site at Henderson, 12km west from the central
city.
They let off a range of fireworks typically sold
for Guy Fawkes celebrations including sparklers, Roman
candles, ground spinners and smoke bombs, says study leader
Dr Joel Rindelaub from the University of Auckland’s School
of Chemical Sciences.
The results over a 10-day sampling
period showed personal fireworks contributed to ambient PM10
concentrations by 21.6 g m-3 over normal levels. PM10
increased over a 12 hour period on Guy Fawkes night to 35.8
g m-3 when normally background PM10 is 19.5 g
m-3.
The use of personal fireworks can expose consumers
to PM10 concentrations much higher, up to 9510 g m-3 from
individual sparkler use under a worst-case scenario, the
study showed. Simply put, that means inhalation of sparkler
emissions for just eight minutes breaches safe air quality
guidelines in New Zealand which are 50 g m-3 exposure over
24 hours.
Extremely high levels of particulate matter
were observed for the green sparkler, red sparkler, blue
smoke bomb, red smoke bomb, and the Buzzy Bees ground
spinner in particular. These items were purchased in a set
that was marketed as a “safer” alternative to large
fireworks, products that would be more suitable around
children and pets.
Despite this, the PM10 concentrations
generated across the product range were among the largest
observed, having a combined average of 5580 g m-3.
The
PM from personal fireworks contained large amounts of
chlorine (Cl), which may be indicative of perchlorate
oxidizers. In addition, lead (Pb) was observed in the PM
generated from two of the coloured sparklers, which were
marketed as “safer” alternatives to more explosive
firework products.
Children are particularly at risk from
pollution from sparklers as they have an increased breathed
air volume per mass compared to adults.
X-ray
fluorescence analysis indicated that potassium (K) and
strontium (Sr) can be used as tracers for local fireworks
and that arsenic (As) may be an important contaminant during
Guy Fawkes.
“This study shows that pollution from
fireworks over the Guy Fawkes celebrations is higher than we
expected and that it can have a short but significant effect
on people breathing in the fumes,” Dr Rindelaub
says.
“The use of some products such as the green
sparklers, red sparklers, green smoke bombs and ground
spinners for less than ten minutes exceeds safe daily
exposure and we think more research needs to be done to
better understand the health consequences of
fireworks.”