Cablegate: Goc Paves Road to Winter Election by Promising
This record is a partial extract of the original cable. The full text of the original cable is not available.
151956Z Nov 05
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 OTTAWA 003399
SIPDIS
DEPT FOR WHA/CAN (HOLST) AND INR (SALCEDO)
USDOC FOR 4310/MAC/ONA
TREASURY FOR IMI
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ECON EFIN PGOV CA
SUBJECT: GOC PAVES ROAD TO WINTER ELECTION BY PROMISING
BIG TAX CUTS, MODEST NEW SPENDING
REF: (A) OTTAWA 2931 (B) 04 OTTAWA 2837 AND PREVIOUS
1. SUMMARY/INTRODUCTION: On November 14 the GOC's annual
Economic Update to Parliament took on new life as the
Liberal Party's campaign platform. In an hour-long
presentation to the House Finance Committee, Finance
Minister Ralph Goodale recapped Canada's strong fiscal
condition and promised a business- and voter-friendly
package of measures that appeal to both the left and the
right. A budget in all but name, the update is also
effectively the Liberals' campaign platform, and it was
announced amid jockeying by all four parties in Parliament
to influence the means and timing of the election call.
2. The centerpiece of the update is approximately C$30
billion (US$25 billion) in personal and corporate tax
reductions over the coming five years, which earned positive
reviews from business leaders. The GOC also promises modest
new spending on post-secondary education, immigrant
settlement, and trade promotion in big emerging markets.
Nevertheless, the update projects continued GOC fiscal
surpluses (in the range of C$8-11 billion annually over the
next five years), even with modest real GDP growth (around
3%). Full details of the GOC's economic update are
available on the Internet at www.fin.gc.ca. END
SUMMARY/INTRODUCTION.
3. BACKGROUND: Since taking office in 1993 the Liberal
Party has presided over spectacular improvements in Canada's
economy. Current Prime Minister Paul Martin, as finance
minister from 1993-2000, led the attack on the GOC's
structural deficits by reducing the size of the federal
government and (in effect) "downloading" many program costs
to provincial governments. In 2000, with ongoing large
surpluses on the horizon and the debt-to-GDP ratio falling,
the GOC delivered substantial personal tax cuts. Since
then, fiscal policy initiatives have focused on restoring
funding to the provincial governments' publicly-paid health
care systems, which suffered during the years of fiscal
restraint and have been the top concern among voters for the
past decade.
4. ELECTION CONTEXT: The ruling Liberal Party, which has
held office at the federal level since 1993 but has been in
a minority in Parliament since June 2004, has braced itself
for a likely winter election by turning its mid-year
"economic update" into a campaign platform. In a bargain
last spring that gained temporary support from the left-of-
center New Democratic Party (NDP), they modified their March
2005 budget by removing corporate tax cuts (ref A). With
the NDP now joining the other opposition parties
(Conservative and Bloc Quebecois) in expressing loss of
confidence in the government and an intention to force an
election, the Liberals have revived those tax cuts and
rolled them into a good-news budget platform that they hope
will get them re-elected with a majority, strengthening
their ability to govern.
5. PERSONAL TAX RELIEF: The main tax relief measures
promised in the update are an increase in the basic personal
exemption by C$500; a cut in the lowest income tax bracket
to 15% from 16%, retroactive to January 2005; and cuts in
the two higher tax brackets by one percentage point by 2010.
Of the estimated C$30 billion in total tax relief over five
years, Goodale estimated that 95% would flow to individuals
and families, with two-thirds to those earning under
C$60,000 a year.
6. CORPORATE TAX RELIEF: The update also promises a
reduction of corporate income tax to 19% from 21% by 2010,
and elimination of the corporate surtax (value: C$2.6-
billion over five years). The document also promises
elimination of federal tax on capital assets in 2006, two
years ahead of schedule (value: C$1 billion over three
years), and extension of carry-forward periods for business
losses and investment tax credits. Goodale also highlighted
his hope that there will be "good progress" on tax treaty
negotiations with the U.S. this winter.
7. SPENDING INITIATIVES: In order to balance its platform
politically, the Liberals included spending initiatives
designed to appeal to the left wing of its party and help to
placate the provinces, including a C$1 billion one-year
investment in universities and colleges, C$2.1 billion over
five years in aid to post-secondary students, C$3.5 billion
over five years for work training programs and C$1.3 billion
over the same period to assist immigrant settlement.
8. TRADE PROMOTION: In keeping with the government's
perennial refrain of diversifying Canada's trade relations,
the update promises C$485 million over five years for a "new
international commerce strategy" for "priority markets such
as China and India," and C$590 million over five years to
develop west coast port and rail infrastructure to
facilitate trade with Asia.
9. CURRENT ECONOMIC CONDITIONS: The meat of the economic
update is impressive. Real GDP growth in Q2 2005 was 3.2%,
up from 2.5% in the previous two quarters. Net exports
continue to rise despite the continued strength of the
Canadian dollar, and domestic demand is solid. Unemployment
continues to decline and, at 6.6% has reached its lowest
level in 30 years. Corporate profits are at 14% of GDP,
also a 30-year record. Interest rates remain low and
inflation, while rising on the back of higher commodity
prices, is within the target range.
10. ECONOMIC ASSUMPTIONS: The GOC bases its update on what
it says are private sector economists' predictions of real
GDP growth of 2.8 per cent in 2005, 2.9 per cent in 2006 and
3.1 per cent in 2007. The GOC cites major risk factors as
being (1) further increases in energy costs, and (2) further
depreciation of the U.S. dollar against all currencies
including the Canadian dollar, which would bring further
challenges for Canadian exporters. Goodale touted the
Liberals' eight consecutive annual budget surpluses and said
that for planning purposes, the GOC expects the following
fiscal surplus in coming years:
2005-06 $8.2 billion
2006-07 $9.2 billion
2007-08 $9.5 billion
2008-09 $7.9 billion
2009-10 $8.4 billion
2010-11 $11.3 billion
11. COMMENT: The Liberal Party is stressing that all these
initiatives could be jeopardized by early elections.
Although specific programs and proposals may die should the
government fall, Canada's solid fiscal performance should
continue. All parties, whether on the left or right, claim
to support prudent deficit-free fiscal policy and continued
debt reduction. The differences in platforms mainly lie in
the speed and nature of tax cuts and the focus of spending.
WILKINS