Racism In Thailand Against Chinese For Coronavirus
BANGKOK, Thailand -- When Thailand's popular,
anti-government graffiti
artist Headache Stencil wrote
racist rants about Chinese infected with
the coronavirus,
many of his Thai and foreign fans were shocked,
outraged,
and disgusted.
"Hey Chink! Please go back to ur
shit-eating country. Our government
need ur money to keep
their power but you all not welcome for us
now.
#notwelcometothailand #backtourchinklandpls," wrote
@headachestencil
on his Twitter site on January 26, which
had more than 6,000
followers.
The English-language
slur against Chinese is not common in Thailand,
so the
artist apparently wanted foreigners to also see his
post.
Headache Stencil often tweets several times a day but mostly in Thai language.
Starting in 2018, he
gained wide support and pride of place in some
of
Bangkok's edgy art galleries when he illustrated
Bangkok's dilapidated
streets with wall graffiti showing
a large clock, politicians' faces,
and other satirical
imagery.
During that year, one of his graffiti targets
was coup-installed
Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwon
who successfully dodged a
financial scandal for
possessing 25 luxury wristwatches worth an
estimated
$1.24 million.
"Disturbing to see such blatant racism
by an artist that used to be
respected by many liberals
in Thailand," tweeted Mathias Peer, the
Bangkok-based
correspondent for the German business
newspaper
Handelsblatt.
"I'm afraid that the debate
over the #coronavirus will increase racial
hatred against
people from China. This is not acceptable!" Mr.
Peer
wrote.
Headache Stencil angrily responded the
same day: "Try to read how Thai
tweets now."
His
broken English appeared to spotlight other Thais who
were
concerned about the spread of the coronavirus and
also tweeting
anti-Chinese comments in Thai
language.
"Oh! Maybe cuz i wrote in English thats why
u understood only my
tweet. No worry. We all want chink
back," Headache Stencil added.
Mr. Peer meanwhile also posted a screenshot of the racist tweet.
"@headachestencil calls me a 'stupid farang'
[Caucasian] after I
pointed out his racist remarks
against people from China.
"It seems like this
well-known government critic is taking criticism
not very
well," Mr. Peer wrote.
Headache Stencil brushed off the criticism.
He claimed, without evidence, that
infected Chinese were coming to
Bangkok because
Thailand's hospitals were better than China's
medical
care -- and endangering the lives of Thais -- so
being labeled a
racist against them was simultaneously
justified and irrelevant.
"Enjoy using my tweet
caption. I dont think Thai ppl will support what
u think
after we knew what chink plan to come to Thailand with
virus
cuz better that hospital in China. Thats call
murderer for me and
others Thai. I dont care to racist
ppl that wanna kill others. Enjoy
yourself," Headache
Stencil wrote.
The Bangkok-based correspondent for
Singapore's Straits Times, Hathai
Pia, said Twitter's
monitors should be informed that the artist is
using
their platform to spread racism.
"You can report the tweets. I did. Quite shocking actually," she tweeted.
"I was one of those who did respect his art,"
tweeted That Daeng Sauce
who is based in Bangkok and
sells smoked fermented sauce. "Not any
more. The total
lack of remorse is even more telling."
A person
nicknamed @megafan44 replied, "Honestly disheartening to
see
him say that. Seems weird for someone to be
anti-dictatorship but also
be a racist."
"It's sad
that this has now developed into hate speech such as
this
racist tweet," wrote Richard Barrow, an online
columnist who reports
about tourism in Thailand. Mr.
Barrow, who has nearly 145,000
followers, also posted a
screenshot of Headache Stencil's quote.
On February 4, Mr. Barrow tweeted an online poll which asked his followers:
"Now that three Thai drivers have been
infected with the #coronavirus
from their Chinese
passengers, what should the Thai government do
now?
"Keep calm and carry on? Ban travel from China? Deport Chinese tourists?
"I really hope 'deport
Chinese tourists' doesn't win. That should
never be an
option. You could ban travel from China, but people
are
now being infected from travel to other
countries.
I think Keep Calm and Carry On is the best
option, but the government
needs to be more proactive,"
Mr. Barrow wrote.
Reflecting the spread of
anti-Chinese racism worldwide because of the
virus,
Thailand's Prachathai news site published on its Facebook
site
an editorial cartoon by Bangkok-based Stephen Peray
which he
headlined, "Sinophobia is now a global health
emergency."
The French cartoonist, who signs himself
as Stephff, drew a big angry
Caucasian man spewing flames
from his fanged mouth, while his balding
head was also on
fire under a hat emblazoned: "Make Racism
Great
Again."
He was yelling at a young woman who
looked Chinese and was pulling her
luggage on
rollers:
"Go back to your sh*@-eating country, you *@#
Ch*+#!" the man shouted
in censored English at the
weeping woman who wore a facemask.
In Thailand's
second-largest city, Chiang Mai police recently told
a
Thai restaurant owner to remove a sign in front of her
eatery which
said in English: "We apologize we are not
accepting CHINESE
customers. Thank you."
Tourist
Police told Waraphat Thapiang, 33, that her sign could
"affect
national security," according to Thailand's
Khaosod English news site.
Surprisingly, police
suggested she could rewrite her sign to say
politely but
deceptively: "We ran out of food" in Chinese.
"I wrote
that sign in the first place because I don’t know which
one
of the Chinese customers who [ate] at my restaurant
was infected," she
said after agreeing to the suggested
rewrite.
Ms. Waraphat wrote the first sign when she
saw worried Thais leave her
Kloijai Khaosoi restaurant in
Mae On district when they realized a
group of Chinese
tourists were dining there, she said.
Chiang Mai is
usually thronged with Chinese tourists who marvel at
its
opulent Buddhist temples, relatively inexpensive
prices, and sites
which featured in films seen in
China.
Thailand does not have laws preventing people
from being barred entry
to places based on nationality,
race, religion, gender, size, age,
odor or other
reasons.
"It’s not illegal. It’s their right to do
so,” Tourist Police Chief
Lt. Gen. Chettha Komolwantana
told Khaosod English.
"However, it’s inappropriate
because it can cause damage to the
country’s
reputation.”
In response, Bangkok-based @RPOBB
tweeted: "True. But we can still
name and shame them. Oh
wait, they can sue back for defamation."
Prayuth
Chan-ocha, who seized power in a 2014 coup and was
elected
prime minister 2019, reportedly surfs the
Internet.
In response to anti-Chinese sentiment
because of the virus, Mr.
Prayuth reminded people that
hate speech was illegal and violators
would be
prosecuted.
China meanwhile allowed Thailand to
evacuate 138 Thais from the
locked-down city of Wuhan to
an air force base in U-Tapao near Bangkok
on February
4.
Some Thais perceived the flight as a slow response
by Beijing after
several other countries were permitted
to fly their citizens out
earlier.
"The delay drove
many Thais to think that Beijing isn't valuing
the
relationship, despite significant pledges by the
Prayuth
administration to buy military hardware,
including the controversial
plan to purchase submarines
worth 36 billion baht ($1.2 billion)," the
Bangkok Post
said in an editorial headlined, "Evacuation is
Long
Overdue" on February 4.
"By giving Thailand
the cold shoulder, Beijing has raised serious
doubts over
whether China was ever really a good friend to Thailand
in
the first place," the newspaper
said.
***
Richard S. Ehrlich is a Bangkok-based
journalist from San Francisco,
California, reporting news
from Asia since 1978 and winner of Columbia
University's
Foreign Correspondent's Award. He co-authored
three
non-fiction books about Thailand, including "'Hello
My Big Big Honey!'
Love Letters to Bangkok Bar Girls and
Their Revealing Interviews," "60
Stories of Royal
Lineage," and "Chronicle of Thailand: Headline News
Since
1946." Mr. Ehrlich also contributed to the chapter
"Ceremonies
and Regalia" in a book published in English
and Thai titled, "King
Bhumibol Adulyadej, A Life's Work:
Thailand's Monarchy in
Perspective." Mr. Ehrlich's newest
book, "Sheila Carfenders, Doctor
Mask & President
Akimbo" portrays a 22-year-old American female
mental
patient who is abducted to Asia by her abusive San
Francisco
psychiatrist.
His online sites are:
https://asia-correspondent.tumblr.com
https://flickr.com/photos/animists/albums
https://www.amazon.com/Hello-Big-Honey-Revealing-Interviews/dp/1717006418
https://www.amazon.com/Sheila-Carfenders-Doctor-President-Akimbo/dp/1973789353/
https://www.facebook.com/SheilaCarfenders